11 days in USVI + Puerto Rico — which combination?

Posted on by

11 days in the USVI and Puerto Rico: choosing the best itinerary for an anniversary trip

A couple is planning a 11-night anniversary getaway from November 25 to December 6 and is weighing vacation options in the US Virgin Islands and Puerto Rico. They’re unsure how to structure the trip and which destinations to include. Their possible itineraries are:

  • Option 1: USVI – St. Thomas, St. John, and St. Croix
  • Option 2: USVI – St. Thomas, St. John, and Puerto Rico
  • Option 3: USVI – St. John, St. Croix, and Puerto Rico
  • Option 4: St. John and Puerto Rico only
  • Option 5: Any other combination

Highlights: St. John’s beaches are repeatedly praised, and the couple loves beaches, hiking, snorkeling, and nature. They’re seeking recommendations from travelers who’ve visited these destinations.

If you’ve traveled these islands, what would you choose and why? Share practical advice on pacing, should-visit spots, snorkeling and hiking trails, and whether combining the USVI with Puerto Rico makes the most sense for an 11-night itinerary.